Sunday 8 November 2009

Notes of what happened on the day

Here are my notes from Saturday's event.
NOTE:this is a rather long and link heavy post, if you were present and notice any errors or omissions let me know (via the comments)

The day started off quite slow, but once we numbered something around 6, the event kicked off.
As we were such a small group, a traditional unconference grid seemed overkill, so we went with a more, "does anyone have anything on this topic?" approach.

First up was Teemu Harju who gave a brief overview of PubSubHubbub. In Teemu's opinion XMPP was not that much harder to code for than HTTP, it's just different.
Teemu saw PubSubHubbub as very important contribution for the move towards the real-time web. He is also working on his own PubSubHubbub server written in Erlang. Teemu also pointed out that the PubSubHubbub definition was only at version 0.2 currently, and still a project dominated by Google Engineers.
As an aside, due to most of the attendees being non-native English speakers they had not realised that hubbub was a real word.

As PubSubHubbub was a Google technology, this brought up the question of "What is the use of Wave?".
After some back and forth conversations, it seems that still for many people Wave is attempting to solve a problem they don't think they currently have.
One good thing to come out of the conversation to use the example of Etherpad to demonstrate the basic use of Wave without having to actually use wave. A useful tip as invites are still relatively limited/restricted

The next topic was OpenID.
The main point from this session was around the usability of OpenID. Once again there seemed to be some confusion around the exact problem that OpenID is attempting to solve.
The use of a URI to login rather than the more traditional regular username or email style username, seemed to be the main sticking point.
One important point was that OpenID would be preferable for Government organisations as it is not tied to a single commercial entity (like Twitter or Facebook)
Although, now the large user communities (Google, Yahoo AOL etc) are all OpenID providers, there is still understanding gap for more mainstream users. The use of a Facebook login was considered more understandable, although most of the people attending had never attempted to use Facebook connect. The actual use of FacebookConnect was at least as poor a user experience as OpenID for me.
One of the attendees (I think it was Aapo Rista) was involved in a project that was building a site based on Django and also using Trac, but was having problems with OpenID. The good news was that during the day he was able to get a working demo up and running, and at least from the demo he gave it seems the Django plugin makes use of OpenID easy.

OAuth was next up. Everyone had heard of it, but all the examples initially were just around Twitter.
Luckily as Kai Lemmetty of Floobs and Arto Luikkonen (who knows the API well) showed an example of using OAuth using the Floobs API.

The next major topic was Open Micro Blogging. Although there was not much interest in this topic by itself, it sparked an interesting conversation about how in places like Africa, services are being built on top of SMS. The concrete example given was of the Masai learning of cattle prices. Also, that this information was increasing the desire of the local peoples to learn to read and write.

As Petri Kola was present (and had just finished two days of rather intense discussions around the topic of Openess at OPEN Symposium) he gave a short presentation of the work he had been doing around open data and getting open access to Government data.

There was also a short session around our generous hosts for the day Hub Helsinki.

As a final note i have to say thanks to Jukka Pellinen for all the help on the day with extra equipment.

2 comments:

  1. Here's a lengthy interview with Chris Messina about where he thinks the social web is currently at, what challenges he sees it is facing and where he would like it ultimately to progress.
    http://www.arcticstartup.com/2009/11/06/open-and-social-internet-what-does-it-really-mean-video/?replytocom=5673#respond

    The obvious question is when do we have the next OpenWebCamp and could we do something else around the topic?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the summary — sounds like there's still a need to drum up interest in these topics, but it's got to start somewhere! Thanks for providing the summary!

    I'm curious about the areas that you discussed — they sound quite familiar to me, especially around OpenIDs as URLs (which is being addressed with WebFinger, enabling emails as OpenIDs) for starters.

    I wonder if there were any thoughts to how it might be easier for you guys to be kept up to date on all these technologies?

    ReplyDelete